‘You’re punishing people’: Doctor slams calls for wealthy to pay health tax in GMB row


Richard Madeley and Susanna Reid welcomed GP Dr Anita Raja and A&E doctor Dr Emeka Okorocha onto Good Morning Britain. They debated the idea of introducing a two-tier system for NHS patients whereby the wealthy pay for treatment while those who can’t afford to, will continue to receive free treatment. 

Emeka furiously hit out at the suggestion claiming it was unfair to “punish people for earning more”.

He said: “We know the NHS needs work, we know the NHS needs funding.

“But as an emergency doctor I just couldn’t be in a position where I was treating patients slightly differently based on what they were earning.

“You have to look at health economics, you’re under pressure from management to meet a number of quotes and then it comes to investigations.”

Read more: GMB sparks uproar as host in Australia after climate change chat

“In A&E we know that some investigations cost more than others,” he continued. 

“Am I going to potentially order you an MRI scan because I know you can afford it or because I know you can’t am I going to think you don’t need an MRI maybe we can get you an ultrasound the next week?”

Susanna interjected: “You’re talking about specifically paying per treatment.

“What Dr Raja is talking about is those earning a bit more, pay a little more into a tax so you wouldn’t know when you’re treating them whether they pay more or not.”

“Where we suffer is A&E,” he said. “If you can’t get a hip replacement, an outpatient appointment, an appointment with your GP, what are you going to do? You’re going to go through the 24-hour system where you know you’re going to be seen.”

However, Anita disagreed with Emeka and argued the NHS could learn from different health systems around the world. 

She argued: “If you look at models from all around the world, especially Germany it’s a completely different model. 

“There should be a completely different model towards the healthcare system, not just the NI contributions.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:


More like this

Hearing aids are now cheaper and easier to buy for hard-of-hearing Americans

There's some good news for Americans who are...

Kylian Mbappe racking up World Cup fines as France pick up the bill for latest tantrum

Mbappe has faced heavy scrutiny at times for...

Beaming King Charles III shrugs off Harry and Meghan Netflix trailer at Sandringham

King Charles III appeared in public this morning...

Liverpool subject of mega takeover bid as Saudi and Qatar chiefs 'join forces'

A wealthy consortium involving high-profile figures from Saudi...